| User | Post |
|
8:19 pm August 28, 2012
| Ariel
| | |
| Admin
| posts 42 |  
|
|
|
*Sniff* We've come to the end of this lovely book. First, thank you for letting me lead this discussion! It was my first time doing so and I had so much fun that I think I'll continue. I've truly enjoyed getting to know each of you a bit better.
I've come up with a few questions that I think will help us navigate Deirdre's character development:
1. I've picked on Tag a lot during this discussion. In all honesty, I think it's because I have a big brother of my own. And we spent many years at each other's throats. I know what it's like to be pestered and humiliated and always in the shadow (in my case, quite literarlly–my brother is six foot six) of your brother. So it was interesting to get that one glimpse into Tag's mind, to see his side of things. We see his unique burden when he tells Deirdre what it's like to provide for his entire family and how he's really on the outside of his ex-wives and children's lives. That prefer him gone. And Deirdre thinks, "I looked at my brother, really looked at him, for the first time in a long time. Maybe ever. It was simply amazing that two people could live in each other's back pockets their whole lives and have completely different perspectives on their shared experiences." So do you think we've had Tag wrong all this time? Is he really in love with himself? Or is he simply trying to hold everything together in the only way he knows how: with his fame? Also, can you think of a time in your own life that you've had a "shared experience" that you viewed completely different that the other person?
2. I think one of the biggest transformations Deirdre makes during the story is when she slips into the role of businesswoman. She nervous about the competition, but behind the scenes she's confident and natural when helping Ilya, the makeup artists, and others create their own business strategies and social networking followings. It's like she comes alive right there on the page. Do you think she would grown into that person if she hadn't run away from her life?
3. Deirdre finally got out of her own way in this last section. She decided to do this crazy thing–really do it–for herself. I could almost feel her relax. And then she danced. With abandon, I like to think. With the closure of that first dance came something just as important as her own personal healing: she made ammends with her family. Parents. Tag. Joanie Baloney. This was the really interesting part for me because I'm so fascninated by birth order and family dynamics. And this question relates to Deirdre as a member of a large and quirky family: could she have really grown as a person without reconciling those broken relationships? Would she have been as emotionally healthy at the end of the book if she'd simply walked away from her family and left that mess unresolved?
4. There was only one thing about this novel that I didn't like. And it's minor. And petty so bear with me here. But I WANTED to know how the Dancing With the Stars competition ended! Did she get kicked off during the first round? Did she make it to the end? What happened! *sigh* I think the story ended this way because Claire wanted to leave us, leaning forward with expectation. She wanted to bring us to that moment of full engagement and let us write the ending. So as we finish this discussion (and Claire, you can chime in on this one if you want) I'm curious to know whether you think I'm right? Why did she end the story after that first dance? And how do you think Deirdre did in the end? Why?
(I think she took Fred and Ginger's fishbowl home, flipped it upside down, and is now using it as a stand for the mirror ball trophy!)
I'll be back on here tomorrow, responding to your answers and with a sneak peek about next month's book.
Thanks for letting me guide this conversation the last few weeks!
Ariel
|
|
|
9:01 pm August 28, 2012
| teresasthoughtsfortoday
| | Evansville, Indiana | |
| Member | posts 39 | |
|
|
Ariel–thanks for the wonderful questions. I sure hope you do stay on as our discussion leader 
1. Yes I have had several times when my mom & I saw certain events very differently. Of course, my view was as a child and her's was as the mom. In fact recently she became rather livid with me about something from my past and it got quite heated between us. Interesting how things are viewed through our own lenses.
I'm not sure about Tag. Maybe his attitude was all a front because he was feeling pressure to provide financially for everyone. I still think he was self-obsessed!
2. I don't think Deirdre would've seen her own potential if she hadn't run away. She would've always been under the shadow of Tag and the rest of her family. I liked this part of the story when she realizes the knoweldge and skills that she does have that could be used for her own business.
3. I don't think Deirdre would've been as healthy. The unbroken relationships would've eaten away at her. I know for myself I either have to reconcile or really break things off and be OK without having that relationship. If a relationship is toxic it needs to be removed. But if it can be reconciled and be healthy, then it is worth it to work on it.
4. I'm with you on this one, Ariel. I wanted to know how she did also. For me, I don't think she won. Since there would probably have been better dancers on the show, ones who had a little experience. I think the book's premise was more about her growing into herself and finding herself with DWTS as a vehicle. Those are my thoughts on why Claire didn't tie it up in a neat little bow for us. Though I really wanted to know if Steve and Deirdre got their "happily ever after."
Thanks for posting these questions a little early for me! I'll probably be able to get on tomorrow for the sneak peak and if it's available as an e-book, I can download it before I leave 
|
|
|
8:31 pm August 29, 2012
| Leigh Ann
| | Algonquin, IL | |
| Member | posts 34 | |
|
|
I also agree with you Ariel, I really wanted to know how Dancing with the Stars panned out for her. My thought is that she did not make the mirror ball trophy, but I do think she made it past the first week or maybe even more. I think she made it past the point she thought she would and was not voted off on week #1.
|
|
|
6:09 am August 30, 2012
| Cindylouray
| | |
| Member | posts 12 | |
|
|
The book was good. I had a little trouble getting into it. Maybe Dierdre's insecurities reminded me too much of me. LOL
I think that Tag was self-centered because that was how he was raised, but he was under a lot of pressure, too, to keep the family afloat. I am not sure if this was self-inflicted or always expected. Both he and Dierdre were at fault here as they had neither one gotten to really know one another, and at the end of the book, they did.
I think the healing was important for Dierdre to continue her self-discovery and healing.
I would say that I doubt she won the mira ball, but she could have. I think, like Teresa, that she likely did not. She won, though, because she came away from the whole thing a new person. Do you suppose she got some more goldfish? I guess Tag got her a fish. I think the pointwas that all of this experience grew her, and maybe grew the whole family. They were quirky, but they were also very close. I was more interested in the happy ever after between Dierdre anhd Steve.
My daughter and I have been seeing something from a different perspective. She says as a punishment I took TV away from her for a year. I doubt that, though it might have been a long time. I asked her when this was and for the rest of the details, and the rest of the details add up, but the year seems unlikely. In any case, if that's true, I would do things differently today.
Ariel, thanks for leading the discussion. It has been fun the very short time I've been involved in it. I have recommended it to a friend who may come on here soon.
|
|
|
10:49 am August 30, 2012
| cammih
| | Siloam Springs, AR | |
| Member | posts 66 | |
|
|
1. NO! We have not "tagged" TAG incorrectly!! I still think he is egotistical and only playing his pity card for his sister .. and then he so rudely answered her phone! But I think Deirdre had a lot of self pity going on too .. and probably a little jealousy toward Tag .
2. I think the job she had with Tag helped her develop into this person .. strong, charasmatic, individual who WAS confident in her job and what she did .. Just insecure with personal relationships.
3. I have a couple of chapters left so I will have to come back to these questions … Quickly!!! :)
|
|
|
7:40 pm August 30, 2012
| Linda A.
| | Northwest, Wisconsin | |
| Member | posts 171 | |
|
|
1. I don't think we have had Tag wrong all this time. Now we just have a wider view of him. He may feel like he has to support his extended family but I still think he is full of himself. I'm sure he doesn't think anyone in his family could survive without him.
As for seeing a shared experience differently, yes, with four siblings we often remember things about growing up differently.
2. No, I don't think she would have grown into that businesswoman without running away from Tag and her family. They would have continued to overshadow her and kept her from seeing her potential.
3. This was a hard question. There are some really quirky families out there and in some cases there is no reconciliation and I agree with Teresa if the relationship is toxic it needs to end. But in Deirdre's case I think for her to be emotionally healthy she needed to reconcile with her family.
4. I don't think she won on DWTS, but I would like to think she wasn't in the first couple of cuts either. I also agree with Teresa that the premise was about her growing into herself and finding herself. DWTS was just the vehicle.
This was a great book!! Thanks Ariel for leading this discussion.
|
|
|
6:38 pm September 2, 2012
| Beni
| | OH | |
| Member | posts 15 | |
|
|
1. We never really know what goes on inside a person's heart and mind. This story was a lesson for me to not judge, because doing so closes doors. Everyone lives seeing life through their own vision. I've known people who I thought had it all together because they were so outgoing and animated, only to realize that they were very insecure and unhappy. However it happened, they ended up living under false pretense, only to discover that while others expect them to be what they personify, it really isn't who they are in their hearts. It becomes a very heavy burden to bear because they feel trapped in fulfilling the expectations of others.
2. I agree with the others. :)
3. Unresolved anger and unforgiveness turns into bitterness and I've never seen an emotionally healthy-and-growing angry or bitter person.
4. I agree; and I like books that let me dream up my own ending! I want to believe that Deidre made it at least half-way through DWTS and maybe even farther – that she was more successful than getting past the first two weeks because she had more talent for dancing than she believed herself to have – she stayed in the dance because through the years the dance stayed in her! And I believe she and Steve got married and lived happily ever after, on their own property in their own home!
Thanks, Ariel! You did a great job! 
|
|
Recent Comments