Week 2: The Guest Book by Marybeth Whalen | Featured Book Club | Online Book Club

Welcome to the She Reads online book club. Each month we choose a novel as our featured selection and meet here for conversation and enlightenment. This is a place where you will meet new authors and new friends, find great books and good humor. Grab a cup of coffee, pull up a chair and introduce yourself!

 
You must be logged in to post Login Register


Register? | Lost Your Password?

Search Forums:


 






Wildcard Usage:
*    matches any number of characters
%    matches exactly one character

Week 2: The Guest Book by Marybeth Whalen

No Tags
UserPost

5:35 pm
July 13, 2012


laurap

Admin

posts 451

Ok, ladies. I think it's official. There is an entire group of women who might suffer an untimely death due to the agony of waiting to discover who the artist is. *SIGH* I hope all of you are enjoying the suspense as much as I am. Not to mention the mental trip to the beach. I've been to Sunset Beach many times in my life (I'm only 2 hours away!), and this story just brings up tons of great memories for me.

I'm posting a day early because I will be at my daughter's dance competition tomorrow and you just never know how loooooong those things are going to last. At least I have a great book to take with me! :)

This week's questions:

1.  Life changed dramatically for Macy, Max, and their mother when their father died. Especially the family's faith. "They'd always gone to the little Methodis church on Ocean Isle Beach when they were vacationing before, but her mother had stopped going to church after Dad died. None of them really had a relationship with God anymore. It was like they were angry at him for taking the core of their family away, and they'd been giving him the silent treatment ever since." Can you pinpoint your faith to a relationship with another person in your life? Was there someone who helped you understand God in ways you were unable to without them? How would not having them in your life changed your faith?

 

2. Nate told Macy to "Live your fairy tale . . . All of it. Don't be afraid of it." What was Macy's fairy tale?

 

3.  At this point in the story, who do you think the artist might be? (Sorry, girls. I just HAD to ask. ;)  )

 

I look forward to another great week and the next round of discovery with all of you!

Sweet Blessings,

Laura

 

    7:52 pm
    July 13, 2012


    Linda A.

    Northwest, Wisconsin

    Member

    posts 171

    1.  I'd have to say it was my mom.  She was an example of God's love in my life.  If not for her strong faith, I would have never come to know God.  My 90 year old father also says the same thing.  He was not a Christian when they met.  And through her he became a believer.  They were married 12 years before he was baptised at the same time as my 10 year old brother.  He tells the story of when he took my mom to meet his family and his sister told him my mom was too good for him.  If my mom had not been there to guide me I really don't know where my faith would be. 

    2.  What was Macy's fairy tale?  The prince on the white horse???  I think she wants someone to love and someone who would love her.  Someone who is faithful and true and won't leave.  What we all want, right? Wink

    3.  I don't knowwwww!!! Confused I don't want to guess, I hate to be wrong!!  But I can hardly wait to find out.  Smile

    7:26 pm
    July 14, 2012


    Beni

    OH

    Member

    posts 15

    The agony of waiting is difficult, but I quickly discovered what works for me! I read all the chapters for the week in one sitting!  It scratches my itch and then I'm more patient!  

    1. I can pinpoint my faith to the relationship I had with my dad.  He mentored me by talking to me about who God was, explaining the scriptures to me, and showing me through his example what trusting in Jesus looked like in every day life.  Much like Macy's dad did, only my experience was real life!

    Without dad in my life, I'm afraid the world would have swallowed me up in my teen years.  Dad never waivered in his faith, no matter what he faced in life; he always pointed me to the Lord and to His Word. He established in me that the Bible is absolutely God's Word and a solid foundation on which I could always stand and that in Christ Jesus I would never be disappointed.  

     

    2. I think Macy's fairy tale includes her dreams of hoping that God is real and really cares, that she would receive His mercy and forgiveness and live in the joy of the Lord like her dad had; and that she would find the artist from the guest book; that the connection she has felt all these years with the artist in the guest book would be reciprocated and lead her to true love and a life of happiness. 

     

    3.  At this point in the story, I'm leaning toward Pastor Nate.  But I refuse to read ahead and spoil it for myself – I love the fact that at this point it could be either one! Great writing!  

    9:32 pm
    July 15, 2012


    teresasthoughtsfortoday

    Evansville, Indiana

    Member

    posts 39

    1. I don't think I really had any one specific person. I didn't have parents who showed me who Jesus is, but I did have grandparents who had a strong faith, but they didn't really talk about it to me. After I became a believer there were people who guided me and helped me to learn how to read the Bible, how to pray, how to lean on God, etc.

    2. I think her fairy tale was to find someone to love her and her daughter, someone she could trust. Also, possibly to do her art.

    3. Ohhhh, I'm like everyone else — just dying to find out who the artist is and if he's someone great! I have 3 ideas — Pastor Nate, Wyatt, and the guy at the art center where her daughter has been going.

     

    Now I can get back to reading the book!!!

    6:41 pm
    July 22, 2012


    ShellySCantrell

    South Carolina

    Member

    posts 182

    1. Like Teresa, there has been more than one person–a lot of people actually–who has spoken to different parts of my faith life at different stages. It's hard to say how my faith would have/would not have been changed if all of those people had not helped shape me. * This question has actually spurred a desire in me to really journal about all of these people and create a timeline… my faith journey. Great question!

     

    2. Meeting the artist… and living happily ever after :)

     

    3.  Okay, in one way I really don't even want to say what's on my mind with this one… but I'm gonna put it out there. It could be any one of the guys we've been introduced to (and I've had all kinds of thoughts about each one and why) but just wondering if it's even possible that it could be Chase????  I think it would be a beautiful redemption story… an opportunity for redemption anyway… and forgiveness… and totally unexpected… and true to real life stories–very believeable. I mean, we all want to "hate" Chase… right? The little girl in me doesn't want it to be Chase… but the big girl I am makes me wonder about how cool it would be and what a dynamic yet crazy thing it would be if it were Chase… and how much healing could happen in Macy's life if it were. 

    Am I twisted or is this making any sense to anybody?

    9:18 pm
    July 22, 2012


    teresasthoughtsfortoday

    Evansville, Indiana

    Member

    posts 39

    Wow, Shelly, I hadn't even considered Chase. Interesting twist!

    2:55 am
    July 24, 2012


    Beth@sportsmomma

    New Member

    posts 2

    1. I would have to say that my parents had the greatest influence on my faith- or maybe I should say the first influence instead of greatest.  Luckily, I have been blessed with many people in my life that have demonstrated a strong faith in God and influenced my faith and my walk with Christ in so many ways. 

     

    2.  Macy's fairy tale – finally meet her "mystery" artist and lives life of true love

     

    3. Ok, I have to admit that my first attempt at being a part of this book club was a "failure" because once I started reading I couldn't stop so I already know the answer but I will not spoil it!  I will say that at this point in the book my mind was literally swirling with possibilities! 

    2:51 pm
    July 24, 2012


    ShellySCantrell

    South Carolina

    Member

    posts 182

    LOL Beth! For what it's worth: I'd consider it a "failure" if you DIDN'T finish the book ; )

    I've really enjoyed reading everyone's thoughts on this section!

    3:57 pm
    July 24, 2012


    Linda A.

    Northwest, Wisconsin

    Member

    posts 171

    Post edited 3:59 pm – July 24, 2012 by Linda A.


    Chase??  I hadn't even thought of that!!

     

    ShellySCantrell said:

     

    3.  Okay, in one way I really don't even want to say what's on my mind with this one… but I'm gonna put it out there. It could be any one of the guys we've been introduced to (and I've had all kinds of thoughts about each one and why) but just wondering if it's even possible that it could be Chase????  I think it would be a beautiful redemption story… an opportunity for redemption anyway… and forgiveness… and totally unexpected… and true to real life stories–very believeable. I mean, we all want to "hate" Chase… right? The little girl in me doesn't want it to be Chase… but the big girl I am makes me wonder about how cool it would be and what a dynamic yet crazy thing it would be if it were Chase… and how much healing could happen in Macy's life if it were. 

    Am I twisted or is this making any sense to anybody?


    No Tags

    About the She Reads Forum

    Most Users Ever Online: 97

    Currently Online:
    8 Guests

    Currently Browsing this Topic:
    1 Guest

    Forum Stats:

    Groups: 1
    Forums: 3
    Topics: 318
    Posts: 2242

    Membership:

    There are 1961 Members

    There are 5 Admins

    Top Posters:

    ShellySCantrell – 182
    Linda A. – 171
    Lane Hill House – 158
    travelingwitht – 136
    cammih – 66
    rthmhlds – 53

    Recent New Members: Vana, Gaylamath, louiserollins, EML, ginabina0183, hannahelizabeth



     

    Grab These Great Summer Reads:

    Support Our Sponsors

    Southern Soap Factory

    Facebook

    She Reads's bookshelf: read

    Blue Hole Back Home: A NovelOne Thousand Gifts: A Dare to Live Fully Right Where You AreThe Lifeboat: A NovelPriceless: A Novel on the Edge of the WorldWatch Over MeJust Between You and Me: A Novel of Losing Fear and Finding God

    More of She Reads's books »
    Book recommendations, book reviews, quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists

    Our Monthly E-Newsletter

    Visit Our Sister Blog

    Novel Matters: Exploring the Craft of Great Fiction

    Book Club Discussion

    What People Are Saying About She Reads

    "I usually get depressed in January, but not this year. Being featured in She Reads this month is as good as a few hours of extra sunlight. Can’t wait to connect with all the wonderful and intelligent readers and bloggers on the site.” - New York Times Bestselling Author of THE ART FORGER, B.A. Shapiro

    “I look forward to reading these books (all of them). I have been a member of a book club for many years and this site is a GREAT resource for material. Thank you for making these books available.” – Book Club Leader, Sheila Waller

    "I was ecstatic to learn Calling Me Home would be She Reads' February 2013 pick. As a longtime fan of the site, I've witnessed the enthusiasm the staff and readers show for each She Reads selection—in fact, I've already noticed a marked increase in buzz about my novel's release due to the She Reads blog network, well ahead of the announcement. I look forward to the opportunity to interact with this fantastic group of smart and sincere readers during the February spotlight on Calling Me Home." - Author Julie Kibler

    "I have coordinated a Book Club for the last 7 years and look forward to passing along this site as well as the authors!” – Book Club Leader Kimberly Yoder

    "I'm so impressed by what She Reads is doing for authors and readers. They continually pick and promote quality books and endorse them both enthusiastically and thoughtfully. The savvy women behind this smart blog really have their finger on the pulse of what women want to read." - Literary Agent Elisabeth Weed

    “With publishers constantly looking for new platforms to promote books, I’m thrilled we are working with She Reads to get the word out about CALLING ME HOME by Julie Kibler and to see the buzz build for this wonderful, moving novel.” - Loren Jaggers, Publicist, St. Martin's Press

    "As the proud editor of THE SILENCE OF BONAVENTURE ARROW, it’s so exciting seeing Bonaventure make his way into the world. She Reads picking this title for its book club is just the sort of word-of-mouth I have been hoping for this wonderful, sweet, and touching story.” - Maya Ziv, Editor, Harper Collins

    “I’m thrilled and grateful that She Reads will introduce Rita Leganski’s wonderful debut novel to the wide readership it deserves.” - Martin Wilson, Publicity Manager, Harper Collins

    "The Silence of Bonaventure Arrow and She Reads are a perfect match: a powerful and unforgettable novel, and women who love great writing. What a joy to be part of this exciting debut." - Literary Agent, Kim Perel

    © 2013 She Reads. Powered by WordPress.

    Daily Edition Theme by WooThemes - Premium WordPress Themes